Casey at the Bat(1916)

“Here's what you've waited years for — the answer to "Why Casey Fanned Out".”

Casey, a baseball hero in Mudville, is revered for his game-winning abilities but struggles with personal relationships, except for his love for his niece and a few children. When his niece gets injured, he's distracted during a crucial game, causing him to lose, and after being shunned by the town, he leaves his lifelong home.